I was in the car with a couple of friends on the way out for the evening recently, and we were musing about some of the high-profile stories about men behaving badly, including Russell Brand and his arrest and court appearances for what sounds like truly awful behaviour towards women. This was before Brand had been found guilty and sentenced to more than 10 years in prison. Good riddance, from everything I’ve read and heard.
A woman in the car with me, perhaps slightly lightheartedly, explained, “They really need to figure out that if they want to get a fuck, they’ve got to give a fuck.” The rest of us laughed, but that’s the reality. There is an epidemic of domestic violence and assaults on women, and it never seems to get better. Reading the news each morning can become really depressing.
One of the people in the car with me works in family violence and child protection, and the stories she tells are hair-raising. It reminds me that most of my friends and I live in a very comfortable bubble. None of us, or few of us, face significant trauma today from our partners or friends, although the same cannot be said for some of my friends and their upbringing, childhood, or previous relationships.
Almost every woman I know has a story of being mistreated by a man that they are or have been intimate with. It might be a boyfriend, a husband, or someone that they went on a date with once. I’ve been on dating apps, but as a man, my experience is completely different from a woman’s.
A fair percentage of men, according to my women friends, don’t even bother with polite conversation. Pretty much the first communication is an invitation to sleep with them, and for reasons that I still don’t fathom, all too often including a picture of their manhood at full mast. What is it with men’s compulsion to send dick pics? You’d think that their success rate would be low, yet they persevere. Maybe it is the one thing they are most proud of. Which is sad.
Perhaps it’s a crude approach, but at the end of the day, it’s a bid for attention. They’re going about it the wrong way, of course. But I suspect any of us who’ve been in a relationship would at least understand one partner trying to attract the other’s attention.
If you're in the middle of this yourself, you're not the only one wondering why the effort in your relationships seems to run one way. I write about men, connection and the small work of staying close most weeks. Subscribe to get the next one.
Zach Brittle, a Certified Gottman Therapist writing for the Gottman Institute, puts it simply.
“A bid is any attempt from one partner to another for attention, affirmation, affection, or any other positive connection.”
I know from feedback from my women friends that often they’re approached by older men, which, for our demographic, means older than 60. Even the lightest conversation gives the impression that many of these men are simply looking for a housekeeper who will sleep with them. They’re divorced, living alone, and have never had to look after themselves because they had wives to do that for them. It is entirely possible that they’ve never actually put a load of washing on or know how to work the air fryer.
I’ve written before about how, in a relationship, women are often the curators of men’s social and emotional lives, and that includes sex: They’ve been getting a fuck without giving one.
“What tends to fill the gap is a romantic partner, which works until it doesn’t. When a spouse becomes the sole container for all emotional needs, the weight is enormous for both people. What researchers describe as secondary loneliness (the isolation of someone who is never technically alone but still has no one outside their relationship to confide in) is more common in men than most people assume, and harder to name precisely because it doesn’t look like loneliness from the outside.”
Psychologist Angelica Ferrara, who co-authored “Theorizing Mankeeping” with Dylan Vergara in Psychology of Men and Masculinities, puts it plainly.
“Mankeeping is the labor that women do to help compensate for the ways that men often have lacking social networks.”
This isn’t just about sex. It’s about acknowledging that, as men, we pay a price if we want to create and maintain relationships with men and women. It might be something as simple as organising a dinner, going to the movies, helping somebody move house, or dropping a text to someone you haven’t spoken to for a while. At the heart, it’s about turning up, being present, and being a good human.
I wrote in my article The Cost of Being the Dependable One:
“I know I am often seen as dependable, I know I am resilient, self-managing, self-starting and independent. It took decades to learn that despite all this, I was lonely.”
So I do know how to put a load of washing on, and I can cook. I can even iron a shirt, but being known as competent and dependable can hide the cracks behind the facade. We can still worry that showing fragility or vulnerability will betray our manliness, or that we’re scared to burden others. What we’re forgetting is that a healthy relationship is based on honesty and transparency. It’s about being authentically ourselves.
What I’ve learned is that I need to give others a reason to call me. Those men on dating apps aren’t giving women a reason.
I think we all need to learn to give a fuck. We can do this in so many different ways. We can do it in our relationships, in our friendships, and in the political landscape. We can give a fuck that too many men still engage in violent, controlling, and coercive behaviour towards women. Those men on dating apps aren’t giving women a reason. We men need to get our shit together.
DO YOURSELF A FAVOUR
That was Molly Meldrum’s line, and it still holds up. You’re reading Alone Rangers for free, that’s not changing. But a paid subscription keeps it free for everyone else and puts a few dollars behind work that’s trying to say something true about loneliness and connection.



